With ongoing refrigeration system problems and no replacement parts available for the old Beacon systems, the McDonald’s owner in Godfrey, Ill., looked to the ingenuity of R.E.C. Service Corp. for a solution. R.E.C. was able to patch the system to keep it running. However, they wanted to offer a viable, long-term solution, one that would deliver energy savings, maintain tighter temperature control and eliminate a nagging icing issue.
When Ross Cailotto, owner of R.E.C. Service, heard about the KE2 evaporator efficiency controller (KE2 Evap) from KE2 Therm Solutions,Washington, Mo.,he knew he found the solution. Before having the KE2 Evap, replacing an old Beacon system with mechanical controls meant moving product from the walk-in to temporary storage while the refrigeration system was off for 8 hours or more. Replacing the old Beacon system with the KE2 Evap reduced the repair time, despite pumping down the system to add an EEV and running the controller wiring. In addition, the KE2 Evap fulfilled Cailotto’s wish list for energy savings, much tighter temperature control and elimination of the icing issue.
“The KE2 Evap provided more than I expected,” says Cailotto. “We are able to use the KE2 Evap for system trouble shooting since it provides real-time superheat readings and electric valve position. Plus, we can view a graph of the coil and space temperature for the past 5 days of history.”
Many McDonald’s restaurants are set up with a combination walk-in cooler/freezer with a door connecting the two through the common wall. The cooler section has a door that opens to the kitchen. The freezer however has an extra door that opens to the outdoor environment at the back of the restaurant. This design facilitates large bi-weekly food shipments without disrupting customer traffic in the restaurant.
To expedite the unloading process, the doors to the walk-ins are often left open while employees run product from the truck into the freezer, cooler and kitchen. Unloading can take up to 2 hours for big shipments. During this time, a significant amount of moisture typically enters the freezer and cooler, especially when the refrigeration systems are running. While this moisture becomes an inconvenience on product boxes when they freeze together, the icy patches on the floor create a potential liability. If it happened to be raining during the delivery, the problems would escalate. Often times, this resulted in a service call a few days after the delivery just to de-ice the evaporators. The KE2 Evap eliminates this issue.
“The KE2 controller pays for itself by eliminating the service calls for de-icing the coils several times a year,” adds Dick Bold, owner of the McDonald’s Godfrey location. “I also like the fact that it is very visible, and that you can scroll the memory to see the history of what’s happening with the cooler and freezer. I also like the fact that it is doing less defrost cycles that were not needed, thus saving more energy.”
One workaround, sometimes used as an attempt to minimize the icing problems on existing systems, is to add a manual override switch to turn the refrigeration off while the door(s) remain open. This creates other issues, as employees can forget to turn the system back on after closing the door. Using onboard relays and communications, the KE2 Evap monitors the doors and manages the refrigeration system accordingly without human intervention. It also sends alarms when doors are left open too long, or when the space temperature is out of range for a specified period of time.
In addition, the KE2 Evap graphing feature confirmed that the Godfrey McDonald’s walk-ins pull down to temperature faster, and that the refrigeration systems are now managed more efficiently. This is significant in terms of energy usage and preservation of food quality.
“I know that with the rise in energy cost, Godfrey continues to reduce its kilowatt usage. And, I feel a lot of the savings are coming from the KE2 controller, thus providing significant dollar savings, both in the short term and more importantly the long term,” says Bold.
Cailotto is also convinced by the KE2 Evap’s performance and feels it is the solution for several other McDonald’s locations he services, as well as other customers.